ASP.Net MVC versus Web Forms

Posted on February 5, 2009 
Filed Under Web Development

We are going to be converting a fairly good sized project over to ASP.Net soon. The process of planning has already started. I have been investigating our options and trying to decide what would work best for us.

I checked out ASP.Net MVC first because that seems to be all the rage right now. I can definitely see why people are excited. I had a fully functioning site up and running in no time. It’s definitely a great framework and introduces a lot of very nice features. I love the testability it introduces into the whole equation, even the view.

What I don’t like, is the fact that it doesn’t support 3rd party controls. With the exception of Telerik and possibly Infragistics, others are SOL right now until the component vendors get their components up to speed. I know Jeff Handley had posted a few articles about extending the base controls, but I’m talking about some serious controls, like Dev Express’s grids and asp editors. I know there are options, but we will never ditch Dev Express. They have been too good to us. When I can e-mail the CTO with an off the wall management question and have him respond within 8 hours, and submit a message to a general e-mail with some questions about their plans and get a phone call from them within 8 hours, that’s not only a company that makes a great product, but a company that cares (shameless plug for you guys Julian and Mehul).

So I started to investigate other options. When searching for some silverlight info, one of my dudes discovered Visual WebGui. Visual WebGui was pretty slick. You drag and drop onto what looks like a Windows Form and where you drop it is where it renders when viewed through IE or Firefox. They also had a small tutorial on how to take a regular Windows forms application and quickly convert it to a full blown ASP.Net web application. This would have been awesome, except we don’t use Windows Forms controls for anything, not even our forms. Everything is from Dev Express, so it doesn’t convert so hotly. I did some more research and you can get those 3rd party controls to work, but it’s not the greatest or easiest to work with. Their quick solution would eventually turn into a code nightmare. So much for that.

Looks like it’s time to dig out the new routing engine in ASP.Net and start wiring up some of my own code. I really wanted to use MVC, but if the UI is going to suck, our users will absolutely hate us.

Comments

Leave a Reply